EducationFor parents · 4 min · 20 November 2026
When your child can't decide
Sohrab Noorsalehi-Garakani“Dr. So”, co-founder of 2Morrow Lab

The deadline is getting closer, and your child changes their mind every day. How to help them decide without making the decision yourself.
The application deadline is in three weeks. On Monday your child wants to do the apprenticeship (Ausbildung), on Wednesday they would rather stay on for the Abitur, the German university-entrance exam, and by Friday they don't know anything any more. You see them struggling, and you may have had an opinion for a long time. It would be so easy to just tell them what to do.
You can help a lot without taking the decision over. A decision your child makes themselves will carry them even when things get hard. With a decision you made, the question always remains whose path it really is.
Why the choice weighs so heavily
Behind the back-and-forth there is often the idea that there is one right choice and that any wrong one will ruin their whole life. With that weight on their shoulders, every option becomes too big.
Bill Burnett and Dave Evans, who developed a course on life design at Stanford University, offer a different view: every person has several good lives in them. So your child is choosing between two or three paths that can all turn out well. That lowers the pressure, and you can tell your child exactly that.
It also helps to ask how easily a choice can be changed later. Someone who starts an apprenticeship after year ten can still get the Abitur later. The Federal Employment Agency (Bundesagentur für Arbeit) lists several ways to do this, for example evening school (Abendgymnasium) alongside a job or a full-time college (Kolleg). Which schools exist depends on the federal state. So many decisions at this age can still be corrected later.
Head, gut and others
For moments like these, our Toolbox has the "Head, Gut and Others" sheet. It comes from exercises by Martin Schwemmle and Klaudia Thal, and one part goes back to the business journalist Suzy Welch. Your child writes the decision down as a question with two options and then looks at it from three directions.
- Head: What is the best and the worst case for each option? How likely is the worst one, and what would I do then?
- Head and gut: How does each option feel in ten minutes, in ten months, in ten years?
- Gut: In ten years I'm sitting in a café with a friend, telling her about this decision. Which story would I rather tell?
- Others: Two people who know me well answer with the five fingers of one hand: what they like, what I should watch out for, what bothers them, what suits me and what I have overlooked.
At the end your child lays everything out side by side, decides, and writes down in one sentence why. They write that sentence themselves.
Your role: one voice among several
Among the "others", you can be one of the two people if your child asks you. Then you answer with the five fingers like everyone else. You don't need a verdict at the end. Your thumb and index finger count as much as an aunt's or a coach's. If your child asks someone else, that's fine too.
An example: Hannah, 16 (invented), is torn between an apprenticeship as a gardener and the Abitur. She asks her father for his five fingers. His thumb: "You're in a good mood after every day in Grandma's garden." His index finger: "Ask the company what the work looks like in winter." Hannah calls them before she decides.
Beyond that, you can smooth the way without pushing. Go along to an open day. Help with the call for a trial day. Suggest an appointment with the careers guidance service of the employment agency (Berufsberatung der Agentur für Arbeit). Conversations there are voluntary and free, and the advisers also hold office hours at schools.
If it is still stuck
Sometimes your child keeps going round in circles despite everything. Then a small try often helps more than another conversation: a trial day, a conversation with someone in the job, a visit to the vocational school. Afterwards at least one of the two options is less abstract.
If you notice that your child is down for weeks, sleeps badly or withdraws, this is about more than a decision. Then get support, for example from the school social worker or a counselling service. If it is about the decision: print out the "Head, Gut and Others" sheet and leave it for your child, with the offer to be one of the two people who answer with the five fingers.
To print: Head, Gut and Others
Sources
- Bill Burnett, Dave Evans: Designing Your Life. Knopf, 2016
- Martin Schwemmle, Klaudia Thal: Sinnovate Your Life, 2024
- Suzy Welch: 10-10-10. Scribner, 2009
- Bundesagentur für Arbeit: Schulabschluss nachholen (Abendgymnasium, Kolleg, Berufsoberschule, zweiter Bildungsweg), arbeitsagentur.de/bildung/berufe-und-wege/abschluss-nachholen
- Bundesagentur für Arbeit: Berufsberatung für Schülerinnen und Schüler (Gespräche freiwillig und kostenlos, Sprechstunden an Schulen), arbeitsagentur.de/bildung/noch-planlos/erfahrungsbericht-berufsberatung-wie-laeuft-das-ab
Our newsletter tells you first when there are new texts and tools for families.
Go to the newsletter
